![](https://jocknroll.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/img_20240622_101046_hdr.jpg?w=1024)
START
Every week I think they’ll be nothing to write about in girls’ and women’s football. I’m always wrong.
THAT’S ENTERTAINMENT
Which game(s) did I watch this week? On Saturday, I took in the 14s East League Cup semi-final between East Fife and Arbroath Youth Yellows in Leven. Games between these two teams have always been entertaining affairs and this one was no different. A clinical Arbroath led 2-0 at half-time. East Fife’s second half comeback, with an early goal, was short lived as the Yellows ran out 4-1 winners. It would’ve been easy for me to stay at home, save some petrol and follow the game on the respective clubs’ Usqor but the weather was good, the football was great (both teams trying to play football the right way) and the coaches and supporters representing both teams are decent people. The referee had a good game too. What more can you ask for? A perfect way to spend a Saturday morning. A three-year old’s birthday party on Sunday meant no football viewing but I got some cake so win-win!
WELCOME TO MY WORLD
Always good to hear of new teams joining the women’s game, so it’s welcome to Benburb WFC and Carron Huskies who are joining the SWFL leagues next season. Good luck to both!
QUIT PLAYING GAMES WITH MY HEART
One of the main talking points in the 18s Cross Region Emma Mukandi league has been the decision by some teams to actively forfeit games against Glasgow Girls rather than play them.
With the collapse of the Youth Performance League at 18s, Glasgow Girls started the season as one of the favourites to win the regional cross region league. However, two very big wins in their first two games (over 40 goals scored with none conceded) gave cause for concern for some teams in the league and I’m told that there was a movement to encourage teams not to play them. In the league, four of their games, for whatever reason, have been forfeited, with another one in the Challenge Cup going the same way. While some of those teams may have had legitimate reasons to forfeit, others were forfeiting games with Glasgow Girls while also looking (very publicly) for friendlies on the same day as the scheduled league match.
Whatever the rights and wrongs surrounding the circumstances* that found Glasgow Girls in that league, teams should be making every attempt to play their fixtures, whoever the opposition is. Saying you don’t want to play a team because you think they’re too strong is a somewhat defeatist attitude, as is actively encouraging other teams to forfeit too. I also get that a heavy defeat can have a demoralising effect on some girls but there’s more benefit from the steep learning curve of a game like that than sitting at home doing nothing. Since those first two heavy victories, Glasgow Girls’ winning scores have been reasonably ‘normal’ (for want of a better word). While they’re still unbeaten, they are by no means runaway leaders in their league. Going into the summer break, they hold a 3-point lead over Giffnock, with last year’s league winners Rossvale, a further three points back.
Before anyone accuses me of being an apologist for Glasgow Girls and taking their side, I should point out that they’re one of the few teams to block my account on Twitter. I tried to find out why last year, hoping to get unblocked but I got nowhere.
(*I’m told that one of the reasons the 18s YPL didn’t go ahead was because some teams from the central belt didn’t want to travel north, in what was supposed to be a national league. I believe there were two, maybe three teams, from North region interested. Teams in the central belt don’t know how lucky they are because the distances covered by teams in the North are horrendous. Would it really have been such a hardship to travel north two or three times in one season?)
RULE THE WORLD #4
From section 12(c) of the Youth Regional League and League Cup Rules 2024:
“Postponement of a cup/plate game shall only occur with mutual agreement between both the opposing teams and the League Administrator. In the absence of unanimous agreement regarding postponement, the original fixture date must be adhered to.”
I’ve chosen this rule for a reason, which I’ll discuss in the next section…
I CAN’T GO FOR THAT (NO CAN DO)
There was a situation recently when both semi-finals of a regional League Cup couldn’t be played on the scheduled date. In each semi-final, one team was unable to field a team (for whatever reason) and requested a postponement. While in one semi-final the teams were in agreement and a postponement was granted, in the other semi-final the host team refused the request of their visitors to play at a later date.
This situation also occurred recently in a 14s League Cup quarter-final when the visitors refused the home team’s request for a postponement and were awarded the tie. The hosts, who only had 10 players and a coach at the Euros, offered a number of alternatives dates and even offered to reverse the tie. I’m told the away team said they couldn’t get a pitch, only for the home team to not only find a pitch but provisionally book it. Despite the home team bending over backwards to get the tie played – even giving up home advantage – the away team refused and were awarded the tie.
Several other ties were also postponed this weekend when both teams agreed to it. It’s credit to them when teams could’ve easily taken advantage of that rule.
The rule mentioned above seems to be weighted heavily in favour of any team who makes a conscious decision (for whatever reason) to refuse to agree to a postponement. It seems crazy to award a game based on a negative decision. Is that really how you really want to “win” a cup tie? Don’t you want to go through on merit by beating the opposition on the field of play? Rules are important but so is common sense. Karma dictates that you might be happy to use that rule in your favour today but somewhere down the road, the tables will be turned, and that rule will be used against you and you won’t be happy about it. What’s sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.
I did ask one of the clubs why they refused to grant their opponents a postponement, but they didn’t respond.
GAMES TWO CAN PLAY
This weekend just past, there were approximately 42 Cup and Plate quarter-finals and semi-finals scheduled to be played. Only 32/33 went ahead. In previous seasons, the League Cups and Plates were done and dusted before the summer break. However, the introduction of the grading friendlies in many leagues has pushed that back. Teams are now pushing back fixtures until August but with the Challenge Cups still ongoing and a lot of league fixtures to be played, there could be some big fixture issues ahead.
While it isn’t always possible, for any number of reasons, I’m a great believer in getting fixtures played when they’re supposed to be played. Experience has shown me that come November teams are scrambling around trying to get fixtures played, sometimes playing three games in a week, and every season there are leagues which are left unfinished.
SATELLITE OF LOVE
So, the new COMET IT system is live. Except it isn’t. Well, it is. Sort of. Clubs were told last Tuesday that “while live it is not currently operational from an SWF perspective”.
The message went on to explain, “That means, that while SWF staff are being trained to navigate the new system, we will not be in a position to advise on COMET’s use or initial challenges clubs may face”.
They said, “It also means SWF will need time to transition to the new system”. I thought that’s what they were already doing or was that just the SFA?
The message continued, “although the system is live it will not yet reflect fixtures and scores accurately…” So, no change from the old system then?! I’m joking, of course. Well, sort of.
SLIGHT RETURN
Last Wednesday I sent to an email to the SFA asking for information about how their NextGen Performance Leagues are decided (points? goal difference? rock, paper, scissors?) and when and where the NextGen Category 2 Cups and Plate finals are being played.
I received an automatic reply, which was split into a few parts. The first three sentences related to the new COMET system, which doesn’t auger well. The fourth sentence said, “we will endeavour to respond within 3 working days”. Not “we WILL respond” but “we’ll ENDEAVOUR to respond”.
[Update: I found out, quite by accident, that all six NextGen Category 2 Cup/Plate finals were being played this weekend just past (22/23 June). Not one piece of information on the SFA website about them (especially if you wanted to watch any of them) and still no reply from the SFA]
SHAME, SHAME, SHAME
While not wishing to sound like a broken record, I have to report of more issues around player, coach and crowd conduct at more than one girls’ game this weekend. It’s always disappointing to hear more stories of coaches being red carded, fighting between players, and opposition parents offering to fight coaches. I also heard of an adult threatening a 12-year-old player.
In what society is that acceptable behaviour? Will it take a very serious injury (or, heaven forbid, something worse) before something gets done about it? Are we going to have a situation where girls’ games get played ‘behind closed doors’, without supporters because parents can’t control their emotions? When are these macho idiots going to take a long hard look at themselves and realise they’re achieving nothing from their actions except making a complete tit of themselves and ruining the sport for their child and everyone else? If the red mist descends on you during a girls football match then maybe you should question if this is the pastime for you. Perhaps tiddlywinks or draughts or maybe knitting might be more your thing.
Football is supposed to be a vehicle for development; socially, physically and mentally. It teaches teamwork, discipline and hard work. However, it seems that a very small minority of coaches and parents seem hell bent on channelling aggression in the wrong way and teaching players the ‘dark arts’ instead of helping them to learn the basics of the game they claim to love.
THAT JOKE ISN’T FUNNY ANYMORE
I usually try and end on a light-hearted note but Scotland’s performance at the Euros was no laughing matter. Thankfully, we have the Tartan Army who continue to support the national team through thick and thin. Some of the pictures and videos on social media from Germany have been hilarious.
On that note, I shall wish you all a good footballing week.
Paul
#GirlsResults
Twitter/X: https://twitter.com/GirlsResults
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/girlsresultsscotland/
Buy Me a Coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/girlsresults
Email: talesfromthe3g@gmail.com